Personal Injury · Comparison · Published Nov 18, 2026
CASEpeer vs Filevine for Personal Injury Firms
For owners and case managers at personal injury firms of one to ten attorneys: what each platform does for the operations jobs, what each costs as listed today, and a worksheet to score the quote yourself.
CASEpeer is built only for personal injury and lists its prices: $90, $130 and $160 per user a month, as listed on Nov 18, 2026 (CASEpeer). Filevine serves many practice areas and sells by custom quote, so it is not scored here. On our operations rubric CASEpeer Pro scores 27 of 28; score Filevine's written quote the same way.
Key takeaways
- CASEpeer lists Basic at $90, Pro at $130 and Advanced at $160 per user a month, with "No long-term contract or setup fee required" (CASEpeer, as listed on Nov 18, 2026).
- Filevine says "Contact our sales team for a custom quote" (Filevine, as listed on Nov 18, 2026), so it is quote only, not scored.
- On our rubric CASEpeer Basic scores 17, Pro 27 and Advanced 27 of 28.
- Filevine sells court rules, the client portal and intake as separate parts: price each one.
- Administrative and client-relations errors were 40.13% of malpractice claims in 2020 to 2023 (ABA, 2026; FirmFooting sum), a gap software alone does not close.
The free SOL Tracking Template is an Excel workbook that drafts each limitations date from your State Rules tab, marks it unverified until an attorney confirms it, warns at 180, 90, 60 and 30 days, and keeps a weekly Review Log.
Get the free SOL Tracking TemplateFor a PI firm, software has one job above the rest: no limitations date gets missed. This comparison scores that job and the other operations jobs, from each vendor's own pages opened on Nov 18, 2026. We take no affiliate fees.
CASEpeer vs Filevine: what is the verdict at a glance?
For a PI-only firm in one office, CASEpeer Pro covers every rubric job at a known price. Filevine suits multi-practice firms and can be judged only on a written quote.
| Option | Best when | Cost as listed | Risk | Our verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CASEpeer Basic | A solo or two-lawyer firm running intake and texting elsewhere | $90 per user a month | No intake module or texting; court rules start at Pro | 17 of 28 |
| CASEpeer Pro | A PI-only firm in one office | $130 per user a month | Court rules run through an integration with no listed fee | 27 of 28 |
| CASEpeer Advanced | Several offices, or a need for an intake portal or API access | $160 per user a month | $30 more per user for features outside the core jobs | 27 of 28 |
| Filevine | Several practice areas, deep configuration, or already on Lead Docket | Quote only | Deadlines, portal and intake priced as separate parts | Quote only, not scored |
Who is each platform built for?
CASEpeer serves personal injury firms only. It was "purchased by MyCase in March of 2021" (CASEpeer support), and since Aug 19, 2025 it is 8am CasePeer, sold alongside MyCase and Docketwise (CASEpeer blog). It says 11,000+ legal professionals use it (vendor figure).
Filevine is multi-practice, serving government teams as well as PI firms, and sells packages: Matters, Intake (Lead Docket), Signatures, Depositions and LOIS, its AI (Filevine). CASEpeer Pro and Advanced list a Lead Docket integration; a firm on Filevine's intake product can keep it either way (CASEpeer integrations).
How do the operations features compare?
Both cover the core jobs; the difference is which plan or package includes each (vendor pages in the sources list).
| Job | CASEpeer | Filevine |
|---|---|---|
| Limitations dates | Statute alerts and notifications on every plan; calendar sync | Statute alerts on the PI dashboard; "deadline chains" and escalation alerts |
| Court rules | CalendarRules integration on Pro and Advanced | Timely, a Matters extension: rules for all 50 states, checked monthly |
| Tasks | Workflows triggered by due dates, case status or age, every plan | Tasks and custom workflows |
| Intake | Intake management and forms on Pro; intake portal on Advanced | Lead Docket, a separate package, with automated text and email follow-ups |
| Client updates | Portal on every plan; two-way texting on Pro and Advanced | Portal as a Matters extension; two-way texting in the case feed |
| Records requests | Records-request status in treatment tracking; requests report on Pro | Tracks which providers still owe documents; request workflows |
| Documents | Storage and document automation; e-signature an add-on | Management and assembly in Matters; e-signature a separate package |
| Reporting | Basic reports; 50 more on Pro; multi-office on Advanced | Custom reports; Periscope analytics as an extension |
| Security | AWS hosting, rolling backups, two-factor login; no independent audit named | Annual SOC 2 Type II audit, ISO/IEC 27001, backups at least every 15 minutes |
Intake carries weight because 26% of PI firms never answered online leads in a 2025 vendor study (Hennessey Digital, Jun 24, 2025).
How did we score them?
On the operations jobs, weighted toward limitations dates, using only what each vendor states for each plan. Each criterion scores 2 (fully met), 1 (partly) or 0 (not stated), times its weight, for a maximum of 28. Vendors with no published price are "Quote only, not scored": features cannot be weighed against an unknown cost.
| Criterion | Weight | Scores 2 when the plan has | Basic | Pro | Advanced |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Limitations and court dates | 3 | Statute alerts plus court rules (1: alerts only) | 3 of 6 | 6 of 6 | 6 of 6 |
| Intake | 2 | Intake management and forms (1: lead tracking) | 0 of 4 | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 |
| Tasks and workflows | 2 | Date- or status-triggered workflows (1: task lists) | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 |
| Client updates | 2 | Portal and two-way texting (1: one of them) | 2 of 4 | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 |
| Documents | 1 | Storage and templates (1: storage only) | 2 of 2 | 2 of 2 | 2 of 2 |
| Reporting | 1 | Report library or custom reports (1: basic) | 1 of 2 | 2 of 2 | 2 of 2 |
| Security | 1 | Two-factor login and a named audit (1: two-factor only) | 1 of 2 | 1 of 2 | 1 of 2 |
| Price | 2 | Published price, no setup fee or long contract | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 | 4 of 4 |
| Total | 14 | Filevine: quote only, not scored | 17 of 28 | 27 of 28 | 27 of 28 |
Review-site ratings and AI add-ons are left out on purpose: neither changes who owns a deadline.
What does each cost?
CASEpeer: $90, $130 and $160 per user a month; e-signature and data migration are extra, with no listed price (CASEpeer, as listed on Nov 18, 2026). Filevine: no dollar amounts, custom quote only (Filevine, as listed on Nov 18, 2026).
Worked example, not a client. A one-office PI firm with three attorneys and two case managers needs five seats: CASEpeer Pro lists at 5 x $130 x 12 = $7,800 a year, Advanced at $9,600. If setup takes 40 hours of paralegal time (our assumption), add about $1,210 at the May 2025 median wage of $30.24 an hour (FirmFooting calculation from BLS OEWS). From Filevine, it requests a written quote for each part.
FirmFooting's Zero-Miss Deadline System sets up date ownership, warnings, escalation and the weekly review inside the software you already run.
See what the Zero-Miss Deadline System includesHow do you score Filevine's quote, and run a fair demo?
Get the quote in writing and score it on the same rubric; each question maps to one rubric line.
| Criterion (weight) | Ask in writing | Score (0 to 2) | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Limitations and court dates (3) | Statute alerts and Timely court rules included? Which jurisdictions? | ____ | ____ |
| Intake (2) | Lead Docket in this quote, or separate? | ____ | ____ |
| Tasks and workflows (2) | Date-triggered workflows and deadline chains included? | ____ | ____ |
| Client updates (2) | Client Portal extension and two-way texting included? | ____ | ____ |
| Documents (1) | Document assembly included? | ____ | ____ |
| Reporting (1) | Custom reports and Periscope included? | ____ | ____ |
| Security (1) | SOC 2 Type II report available under an NDA? | ____ | ____ |
| Price (2) | Per-user price for each part, setup fee, minimum term | ____ | ____ |
| Total (14) | Compare with CASEpeer Basic 17, Pro 27, Advanced 27 | ____ of 28 |
Then run the same three matters through both demos, with sample data only:
- A new inquiry to an opened matter: incident date with its source, the public-body question, a drafted limitations date confirmed by an attorney, and warnings reaching two people.
- A records request: logged with a response due in 30 days, a follow-up task, and what happens when it goes overdue.
- A client update during treatment: a scheduled 30-day update, a text, and the last-contact date on a dashboard.
Price any workaround a demo needs before you sign.
What will you still have to configure?
The system around the software: who owns each date, who backs it up, who reviews every date weekly, and what happens when a warning is ignored. In the ABA's 2020 to 2023 Profile, administrative errors were 22.87% of claims and client relations 17.26%, and "failure to calendar properly" and "failure to react to calendar" ranked first and third among administrative errors (ABA, 2026).
"Administrative and client relations issues are uniquely within the control of law firms."
Mark Fucile, WSBA NWSidebar, Oct 22, 2020, on the prior ABA Profile
Two rules frame the choice. North Carolina's Comment [8] to Rule 1.1 asks lawyers to "keep abreast of changes in the law and its practice, including the benefits and risks associated with the technology relevant to the lawyer's practice" (NC Rule 1.1, Comment [8]). And Rule 1.6(c) is why security carries weight on the rubric: "A lawyer shall make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation of a client" (NC Rule 1.6(c)). Check your own state's versions.
Three mistakes to avoid:
- Migrating before deciding how the firm works. Fix: the configuration-first method.
- Trusting a drafted date. Fix: dates stay unverified until an attorney confirms them (PI SOL tracking).
- Buying the top plan for unused features. Fix: score plans on your jobs.
Frequently asked questions
Is CASEpeer or Filevine better for a small personal injury firm?
For a PI-only firm in one office, CASEpeer Pro covers the operations jobs at a listed price and scores 27 of 28 on our rubric. Filevine suits firms with several practice areas or deep configuration needs; score its written quote the same way.
How much does CASEpeer cost?
As listed on Nov 18, 2026, CASEpeer Basic is $90, Pro $130 and Advanced $160 per user a month, with no long-term contract or setup fee required.
How much does Filevine cost?
Filevine does not publish prices. It sells packages and extensions by custom quote, so ask for a written quote that prices each part you will use.
Do CASEpeer and Filevine track statutes of limitations?
Both send statute of limitations alerts. Neither decides the period: the attorney sets each date, and the firm still needs an owner, a backup, early warnings and a weekly review configured around the alerts.
Which CASEpeer plan does a small PI firm need?
Usually Pro, which adds intake management, two-way texting and a court-rules integration. Advanced adds multi-office reporting, an intake portal, scheduled texts and API access.
Is this comparison sponsored?
No. FirmFooting takes no affiliate fees, referral payments or sponsorships from any vendor, and scores only what each vendor states on its own pages.
Sources
- CASEpeer, pricing page (plan features and prices, as listed Nov 18, 2026). casepeer.com/pricing
- CASEpeer, feature pages: case management, practice management, integrations (Nov 18, 2026).
- CASEpeer, MyCase acquisition article and 8am rename post, Aug 19, 2025. support center; blog
- Filevine, pricing page (packages; no published prices, as listed Nov 18, 2026). filevine.com/pricing
- Filevine, product pages: personal injury, case management, Timely, intake, security (Nov 18, 2026).
- ABA Standing Committee on Lawyers' Professional Liability, The Law Firm Liability Landscape, CLE materials, Jul 29, 2026 (Profile of Legal Malpractice Claims, 2020 to 2023). PDF
- Mark Fucile, Risk Management by the Numbers: New ABA Study on Malpractice Claims, WSBA NWSidebar, Oct 22, 2020. nwsidebar.wsba.org
- North Carolina State Bar, Rules of Professional Conduct: Rule 1.1, Comment [8]; Rule 1.6(c).
- Hennessey Digital, 2025 List of Fastest-Responding Personal Injury Firms, Jun 24, 2025 (vendor study). hennessey.com
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025, paralegals and legal assistants (23-2011). bls.gov/oes/tables.htm
Where to go next
- Personal Injury Law Firm Operations: Every Guide
The PI hub and every guide.
- PI Statute-of-Limitations Tracking
The system behind the alerts.
- PI Intake Speed
The response standard.
- Clio vs MyCase for Small Firms
The same lens, general practice.
- Legal Software Comparisons
Every comparison, scored the same way.
- What Law Firm Operations Consulting Costs
What the system build costs.
Whichever platform you pick, check that every date has two names
Start with the free SOL Tracking Template as your second record of every limitations date. Then book the free 30-minute Missed-Deadline Risk Audit: we look at how your dates are owned and escalated, using matter numbers only.