Websites & AI Search · Build in public · Published Nov 19, 2026
Law Firm Blog SEO: What 150 Briefs Taught Us About Indexing
For firm owners about to publish a lot of content, in-house or through an agency: our own Search Console numbers, what made Google stop indexing a new site, what we changed, and the monthly check that would have caught it sooner.
Law firm blog SEO starts with getting pages indexed, not with publishing more. Google Search Console showed our site flat at 38 indexed pages, with 83 "Discovered, currently not indexed," from mid-September to late October 2026. After we fixed internal links, sitemap dates and duplicates, the Nov 9 report showed 129 indexed and 5 not. Publish steadily and link everything.
Key takeaways
- Search Console, report of Oct 23, 2026: 38 indexed, 86 not indexed, 83 of them "Discovered, currently not indexed" (first-party).
- Report of Nov 9, 2026: 129 indexed, 5 not, two weeks after the structural fixes went live on Oct 26 (first-party).
- Our Oct 22 crawl found the main library page linked 90 of 118 briefs and sitemap dates going back to June 2026, before the site existed (first-party).
- Google uses
lastmodonly if it is "consistently and verifiably" accurate (Google Search Central, opened Nov 19, 2026). - Bing Webmaster Tools counted 46 citations of our pages in AI answers over the three months to Nov 13, 2026, and 150 briefs were live on Nov 18 (first-party).
Get the free template
We publish our own numbers. We launched a large library of operations briefs in the second half of 2026 and expected Google to index it within weeks. For about six weeks it indexed a fraction. This is exactly what Search Console and our crawler recorded, what we think went wrong, and what we changed. Today 150 briefs are live; the lessons came from the first 118.
What did Search Console actually show?
A count that stopped moving. Search Console's page indexing report is the plainest view of how Google treats a site, and ours read 38 indexed from mid-September through its Oct 23, 2026 update, with 83 pages marked "Discovered, currently not indexed." Google explains that status this way: "The page was found by Google, but not crawled yet," usually because Google "wanted to crawl the URL but this was expected to overload the site" and rescheduled (Search Console Help, page indexing report, opened Nov 19, 2026).
| Measure | Before | After | Tool and date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indexed pages | 38 | 129 | Search Console, reports of Oct 23 and Nov 9, 2026 |
| Not indexed | 86 | 5 | Same |
| Discovered, currently not indexed | 83 | 0 | Same (Nov 9: 1 redirect, 1 not found, 1 crawled not indexed, 2 noindex) |
| Pages in the sitemap | 124 | 155 | Bing sitemap read Oct 29; our sitemap Nov 18, 2026 |
Two cautions. Google says plainly: "Don't expect every URL on your site to be indexed" (Search Console Help). And the jump came after our fixes, but Google does not say why it indexes a page, so we report the sequence, not proof of cause.
Why did Google stop indexing a new law firm blog?
Our diagnosis: a new domain with almost no outside links presented well over a hundred long pages in a short time, and our own structure gave Google little reason to go further. Thirty briefs went live on a single day, Sep 7, 2026, and 10 of them had no internal link pointing at them (our Oct 26 audit). Google's spam policies describe "Scaled content abuse" as "when many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings" (Google Search Central). Our pages were written for readers, but volume plus weak signals is a pattern a crawler meets cautiously.
What did we get wrong?
Five things, all avoidable, each found in our own records.
| Problem | Evidence | Fix | Date fixed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wrong sitemap submitted | Search Console error "Sitemap is HTML": the homepage was submitted, not /sitemap.xml | Submitted /sitemap.xml | Sep 2026 |
| Pages nobody links to | Library page linked 90 of 118 briefs; 28 newest only on a rotating homepage list; 10 with zero inbound links | Related block of 5 same-topic links on every brief (Oct 26); 3 or more in-text links from other briefs (Nov 12) | Oct 26, Nov 12 |
| Untrustworthy dates | Sitemap lastmod back to June 2026; Sep 7 pages dated Aug 4 to Sep 7 | Sitemap regenerated with true dates; new pages dated the day they go live | Oct 26 |
| Duplicate and dead pages | Two indexable copies of one deadline guide; 47 links to a page that did not exist | Duplicate retired with a 301; dead links pointed to the free Template Library | Oct 26 |
| Overlong titles and descriptions | 68 titles over 60 characters (Oct 26); 118 descriptions over 155 (Nov 12 crawl) | All titles cut to 60 or fewer; descriptions to 155 or fewer | Nov 12 |
On dates, Google is explicit: "Google uses the <lastmod> value if it's consistently and verifiably (for example by comparing to the last modification of the page) accurate," and "Google ignores <priority> and <changefreq> values" (Google Search Central, build a sitemap). A sitemap that claims edits before the site existed teaches the crawler to ignore it. On links: "Every page you care about should have a link from at least one other page on your site" (Google Search Central, crawlable links). We had ten that did not.
The free Monthly Operations Report Template gives the owner one page of numbers each month. Indexed pages and organic inquiries fit on its intake lines.
Get the free templateWhat did we change, and when?
- Oct 26: structure. Every brief got a related block of five same-topic links; 30 bare September pages got the full site header and footer; the sitemap was regenerated with true dates; one duplicate was retired with a 301.
- Oct 26: tell the engines. We resubmitted the sitemap in Search Console, added the site to Bing Webmaster Tools, and sent all URLs through IndexNow, which accepted 121. IndexNow shares submissions with participating engines such as Bing, Naver, Seznam.cz, Yandex and Yep; Google is not listed (IndexNow FAQ). A 200 response "only indicates that the search engine has received your URL" (IndexNow documentation).
- Oct 26 onward: pace. One new brief a day, dated the day it went live. From Nov 11, five a weekday, with a weekly gate before stepping up: the indexed count rising, and "Discovered" growing by no more than about 1 in 5 of the week's new URLs.
- Daily: ask, a little. We requested indexing for about 10 pages a day. Google notes "there's a quota for submitting individual URLs" and that asking twice "won't get it crawled any faster" (Google Search Central).
- Nov 12: crawl and clean. Our Screaming Frog crawl found 206 internal URLs, 0 errors, 0 orphan pages and a maximum depth of 3 clicks. We repointed 24 citations that redirected, cut every title to 60 characters and every description to 155, and made sure each brief has at least 3 in-text links from other briefs.
The monthly indexing check (copy this)
Fifteen minutes, first business day of the month, owned by whoever runs the website, reviewed by the owner. Stop publishing new pages when the warning column trips.
| Line | Where | Warning sign | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Indexed pages | Search Console, Pages | Flat for 4 weeks while you publish | Pause new pages |
| Discovered, not indexed | Same report | Grows faster than 1 in 5 new URLs | Fix links and duplicates first |
| Pages with no inbound link | A crawler (orphans) | More than 0 | Link from the hub and 2 related pages |
| Sitemap lastmod | Your sitemap file | Any date before the page existed | Regenerate from real edit dates |
| Two pages, one question | Search Console, queries by page | Two URLs on the same query | Merge with a 301 |
| Organic sessions and inquiries | GA4 and the intake log | Sessions rise, inquiries do not | Fix the next step on top pages |
Status words in the report mean different things, so read them with Google's definitions beside you.
| Status | Google's explanation | What we did |
|---|---|---|
| Discovered, currently not indexed | "The page was found by Google, but not crawled yet." | Links, dates, pace |
| Crawled, currently not indexed | "Google doesn't index all pages across the web, so this is a common message for many sites" | Improve or merge the page |
| Page with redirect | "This is a non-canonical URL that redirects to another page." | Nothing; our retired duplicate shows here by design |
| URL marked noindex | Google "encountered a 'noindex' directive and therefore did not index it" | Nothing for pages kept out on purpose |
What differs for immigration, family and PI firms?
Immigration firms publish pages whose facts change monthly (fees, forms, processing times): update and re-date them honestly, which is exactly when a true lastmod helps. Family law firms often write many similar state-procedure pages; check them for overlap before publishing the next. Personal injury firms buy content at volume from agencies more than most; ask for a steady schedule and a hub for every topic. For all three, every post is attorney advertising: no promised outcomes, and check your state bar's rules.
What to do this week
- Open Search Console, Pages, and write down indexed and "Discovered, currently not indexed" with the report date.
- Check that the sitemap submitted is the XML file, and that no lastmod predates the page.
- List posts that no other page links to, and link each from its topic hub and two related posts.
- Pause new posts if indexed has been flat for a month, and fix structure first.
- Add the monthly check to the owner's report.
Frequently asked questions
What does "Discovered, currently not indexed" mean in Google Search Console?
Google found the page but has not crawled it yet, usually because it rescheduled the crawl. On our site 83 pages sat in that status from mid-September to late October 2026; by the Nov 9 report none did.
Is publishing a lot of blog posts good for a law firm's SEO?
Not on its own. On a new domain, many pages at once with weak internal links can stall indexing, as ours did at 38 pages. Publish steadily, link every post from a hub and related posts, and watch the indexed count.
How do you get Google to index pages it is ignoring?
Fix internal links so every page has at least one link from another page, keep sitemap dates true, retire duplicates with a 301, then request indexing for the most important pages. Requesting the same URL twice does not speed it up.
Does IndexNow work with Google?
Google is not listed among IndexNow's participating search engines. IndexNow sends URLs to engines such as Bing and Yandex; for Google, use the sitemap and Search Console.
How long does it take a new law firm blog to get indexed?
It varies, and Google says crawling can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. Our count sat at 38 for about six weeks, then reached 129 within two weeks of our structural fixes.
Sources
- FirmFooting Google Search Console, page indexing reports of Oct 23 and Nov 9, 2026; sitemap status. First-party.
- FirmFooting Bing Webmaster Tools, AI Performance, last 3 months, read Nov 13, 2026. First-party.
- FirmFooting site audit of Oct 22 and Oct 26, 2026, and Screaming Frog crawl of Nov 12, 2026. First-party.
- Search Console Help, page indexing report. support.google.com
- Google Search Central, build and submit a sitemap. developers.google.com
- Google Search Central, spam policies. developers.google.com
- Google Search Central, ask Google to recrawl your URLs. developers.google.com
- Google Search Central, make your links crawlable. developers.google.com
- IndexNow documentation and FAQ. indexnow.org/documentation; indexnow.org/faq
Where to go next
- Law firm website and AI search library
Every website guide.
- AI assistant referrals: how to track them
Our AI tracking setup.
- AI search and "lawyer near me"
Making each page worth citing.
- The GA4 key events that matter
Count the inquiries the traffic brings.
Make every post findable, then make it answer
Get the free Monthly Operations Report Template to put indexing and inquiries on one page, or book the free Missed-Deadline Risk Audit to see where inquiries and dates slip. When the site needs rebuilding on a clean structure, Client Door is FirmFooting's website build, wired to intake.