Intake & Client Comms · Comparison · Published Nov 13, 2026 · Updated Nov 2026

Ruby vs Smith.ai for Law Firm Intake: A Head-to-Head

Ruby and Smith.ai are the two answering services small law firms compare most. Both answer calls live around the clock and connect to the major practice management tools. They differ in pricing, intake work and use of AI. Here is Ruby vs Smith.ai.

Ruby bills by the minute: on Nov 13, 2026 its plans ran from $250 for 50 minutes to $1,725 for 500, with a live receptionist on every call. Smith.ai's human-first plans bill by the call, from $300 for 30 calls to $2,100 for 300, with per-call legal add-ons, and its AI receptionist starts with a free tier. Ruby suits short calls; Smith.ai suits structured intake on every call.

Key takeaways

  • Ruby prices by the minute, billed in 60-second increments; Smith.ai prices by the call.
  • At list prices the two cost the same when Ruby's billed time averages about 2 to 2.5 minutes a call.
  • Both answer 24/7 with live people and offer Spanish.
  • Smith.ai sells per-call legal add-ons: extended intake, conflict checks, booking, payments.
  • Smith.ai also sells AI-only receptionist plans; Ruby uses AI to assist its humans.
  • Both integrate with Clio, MyCase and Lawmatics.
  • Neither decides conflicts or engagement; the attorney does.

Our roundup of Smith.ai alternatives covers the answering-service market broadly. This head-to-head narrows to the two names small firms shortlist most often, because the choice between them usually comes down to a few concrete differences: how calls are billed, how much intake work happens on each call, and how much AI is involved. We take no affiliate fees from either, and every vendor figure here is from the vendors' own pages, checked on Nov 13, 2026. Before choosing either, it helps to know your own call pattern, which the intake mystery-shop will show you.

Why does answering every call matter for a law firm?

Because most firms miss the call: in Clio's 2024 secret-shopper study, only 40% of firms answered a prospective client's phone call, down from 56% in 2019, and 48% were essentially unreachable by phone (Clio, 2024). Email fared no better: only 33% of the 500 firms emailed replied, down from 40% in 2019 (Clio, 2024). Prospects expect speed: in Clio's 2019 consumer research, 79% expected a response within 24 hours (Clio, 2019). An answering service closes the first gap, the unanswered ring. It does not close the second, the slow callback, which is why the follow-up section below matters as much as the vendor you pick. Our intake SLA guide charts the full secret-shopper results.

Ruby vs Smith.ai: how do their pricing models differ?

Ruby's pricing page lists receptionist plans by minutes per month: $250 for 50 minutes, $395 for 100, $720 for 200 and $1,725 for 500, with no fees for activation, onboarding or setup, plus live chat packages from $143 for 10 chats, or 20% less when added to a receptionist plan (Ruby, 2026). Ruby's FAQ says there is no long-term contract, and that minutes beyond the plan are billed at "the overage rate associated with your plan", a rate the site does not publish. Smith.ai's pricing page lists its human-first plans by calls: Starter at $300 for 30 calls, Basic at $810 for 90 and Pro at $2,100 for 300, with extra calls at $11.50, $10.50 and $8.50, month-to-month, and a 10% discount for subscribing for 12 months (Smith.ai, 2026). The practical difference: a per-minute plan rewards short calls, and a per-call plan rewards longer ones. A firm whose calls are mostly quick messages pays less per call with minutes; a firm whose calls involve real intake questions may pay less per call with a per-call plan, especially once intake is added.

Ruby vs Smith.ai at a glance (vendor pages, checked Nov 13, 2026; verify before buying)
AreaRubySmith.ai
Pricing unitReceptionist minutes per month, billed in 60-second incrementsCalls per month
Entry plan$250 for 50 minutes$300 for 30 calls
Larger plans$395 for 100, $720 for 200, $1,725 for 500 minutes$810 for 90, $2,100 for 300 calls
OveragePlan's overage rate; not published$11.50, $10.50 or $8.50 per extra call by plan
ContractNo long-term contract; cancellation effective at the end of the monthly billing periodMonth-to-month; 10% off a 12-month subscription
Money-back guaranteeFirst-time customers: within 21 days or before 500 receptionist minutes, whichever comes firstNew clients: 30 days, plan and add-ons up to $1,000, overage excluded
Coverage24/7; Spanish bilingual service included at no extra cost24/7 included; dedicated Spanish line $1.00 per call
Legal extrasIntake, scheduling and payment collection inside the minutesPer-call: extended intake, conflict check, booking, payments
AIAI assists human receptionists, included in every planSeparate AI-first and hybrid plans, plus human-first plans
Price per included unit on each Ruby and Smith.ai receptionist plan, November 2026 Horizontal bars. Ruby, price per included minute: 50-minute plan 5.00 dollars, 100-minute plan 3.95, 200-minute plan 3.60, 500-minute plan 3.45. Smith.ai human-first, price per included call: Starter 30 calls 10.00 dollars, Basic 90 calls 9.00, Pro 300 calls 7.00. Calculated as plan price divided by included units. Sources: Ruby and Smith.ai pricing pages, checked November 13, 2026. What one included unit costs Plan price divided by included minutes (Ruby) or calls (Smith.ai), USD Ruby, 50 min for $250 $5.00 a minute Ruby, 100 min for $395 $3.95 a minute Ruby, 200 min for $720 $3.60 a minute Ruby, 500 min for $1,725 $3.45 a minute Smith.ai, 30 calls for $300 $10.00 a call Smith.ai, 90 calls for $810 $9.00 a call Smith.ai, 300 calls for $2,100 $7.00 a call Sources: Ruby and Smith.ai pricing pages, checked Nov 13, 2026.
A Smith.ai call costs about two Ruby minutes. Included units only; overage is billed separately. Source: Ruby, 2026; Smith.ai, 2026.

How does Ruby count a minute, and Smith.ai a call?

Ruby bills receptionist time in 60-second increments, rounding every call up to the next full minute, while Smith.ai bills each call as one unit whatever its length, according to the two vendors' own FAQs (Ruby, 2026; Smith.ai, 2026). Ruby's clock runs from the moment a receptionist receives the call until it is transferred, sent to voicemail or ends, and it includes hold time and any time the receptionist spends completing your call notes after the caller hangs up; once a call is transferred to you, your talk time is not counted. Ruby's app alerts you when you have used 85% and 100% of your plan's minutes. Smith.ai does not charge for spam or unsolicited sales calls on its receptionist plans as long as the lines you forward pass caller ID; on its AI receptionist, every answered call counts by default, with an allowance to remove up to 10% of calls each billing cycle as spam (Smith.ai, 2026).

When Ruby and Smith.ai cost the same (arithmetic from list prices checked Nov 13, 2026; included units only, before overage)
Plan pairingRuby, per minuteSmith.ai, per callBreak-even Ruby minutes per callBreak-even with Smith.ai intake add-ons (+$3.50)
Ruby 50 min ($250) vs Smith.ai Starter ($300)$5.00$10.002.02.7 ($13.50 a call)
Ruby 200 min ($720) vs Smith.ai Basic ($810)$3.60$9.002.53.5 ($12.50 a call)
Ruby 500 min ($1,725) vs Smith.ai Pro ($2,100)$3.45$7.002.03.0 ($10.50 a call)

Read the table this way: if Ruby's billed time on your calls averages under about two minutes, Ruby costs less per call at list price; above that, Smith.ai's per-call price wins, and the gap widens once each call includes real intake. The last column adds the three Smith.ai add-ons a law firm intake call typically uses, extended intake ($1.50), a conflict check ($0.50) and booking ($1.50). Remember the rounding: a call of 2 minutes and 10 seconds bills as 3 Ruby minutes. Pull your average call length from your phone system before you choose, and compare it against billed minutes, not talk time.

Ruby's legal page describes 24/7 live answering, appointment scheduling and client intake, and help with payment collection, and its integrations page lists native integrations "such as Clio" plus 8am MyCase, Filevine, Lawmatics, Law Ruler and Rocket Matter among its legal connections (Ruby, 2026). Smith.ai's legal page goes further on structured intake and its pricing page prices each piece per call: five short-answer intake questions are included, then six more questions cost $1.50, a conflict check against your CRM $0.50, appointment booking $1.50, payment collection $1.00 and a dedicated Spanish line $1.00 (Smith.ai, 2026). Smith.ai's pricing page names Clio among the CRMs it sends call details to, its integrations directory lists 8am MyCase, and its legal page shows Lawmatics among its legal integrations. A receptionist running a "conflict check" is searching names in your system; the decision about whether a conflict exists, and whether to take the matter, stays with the attorney.

An answered call, start to finish A call is answered live, intake questions are asked, names are searched for conflicts, a consultation is booked, and the record lands in the firm's system for a named owner to follow up. Smith.ai prices several of these steps per call; Ruby covers them inside its per-minute plans. An answered call, start to finish 1 Answered live24/7 by a receptionist, or by AI if you buy an AI plan 2 Intake questionsYour script: Smith.ai includes 5, Ruby bills the minutes they take 3 Name searchA conflict search in your system, not a conflict decision 4 Consultation bookedOn your calendar: $1.50 a call at Smith.ai, inside Ruby's minutes 5 Logged to your systemA named owner reviews it the same day and follows up The service answers; the firm owns the next step
Green path from call to owned follow-up. The service answers; the firm owns the next step. Source: Smith.ai, 2026; Ruby, 2026.
Know your call pattern before you buy

The free audit includes a quick look at how your firm handles new inquiries today, which tells you whether per-minute or per-call pricing fits. Metadata only.

Book the free Audit

What do Smith.ai's legal add-ons cost per call?

Smith.ai includes five short-answer intake questions, lead qualification and one CRM integration on every receptionist plan, then charges per call for extras: $1.50 for six more intake questions, $0.50 for a conflict check, $1.50 to book an appointment and $1.00 to take a payment, among others (Smith.ai, 2026).

Smith.ai per-call add-on prices on its human-first receptionist plans, November 2026 Horizontal bars, price per call in dollars: extended intake, six more questions, 1.50; book appointments 1.50; complex call routing 1.50; dedicated Spanish line 1.00; accept payments 1.00; third-party intake form 1.00; custom calendaring 1.00; conflict checks 0.50; text and email follow-up 0.50; SMS or Slack transfer alert 0.50; accept collect calls 0.50; each additional CRM 0.50; call recording and transcription 0.25; each custom intake question 0.25. Source: Smith.ai pricing page, checked November 13, 2026. Smith.ai prices intake piece by piece Per-call add-on prices, USD, on top of the plan's per-call price Extended intake (6 more questions) $1.50 Book appointments $1.50 Complex call routing $1.50 Dedicated Spanish line $1.00 Accept payments $1.00 Third-party intake form $1.00 Custom calendaring $1.00 Conflict checks $0.50 Text and email follow-up $0.50 SMS or Slack transfer alert $0.50 Accept collect calls $0.50 Each additional CRM $0.50 Call recording and transcription $0.25 Each custom intake question $0.25 Source: Smith.ai pricing page, checked Nov 13, 2026.
Five short intake questions are free; everything past that is metered. Source: Smith.ai, 2026.

Monthly extras sit on top: business caller ID for outbound calls is $10 a month, each additional transfer destination $15 a month (Starter includes one, Basic two and Pro ten), and inbound call tracking numbers $5 each per month (Smith.ai, 2026). Ruby, by contrast, lists scheduling, bilingual answering, payment collection and lead qualification and intake among the features of every receptionist plan, with no per-call charge; you pay for them through the minutes they take (Ruby, 2026).

How does each use AI?

The two have taken different approaches. Ruby's FAQ says it "is not an automated virtual receptionist": a real receptionist answers every call, and its AI page lists Call Nav, an assistant that pulls your business information for the receptionist during the call, plus call and voicemail transcripts, sentiment analysis and robocall filtering, all included at no extra cost in every plan (Ruby, 2026). Smith.ai sells three approaches. Its AI receptionist has a free tier with 25 calls a month and $3.00 for each call after that, a Pro tier from $150 a month for 75 calls ($2.00 a call) to $500 for 300 ($1.67 a call), and Enterprise plans from $500 a month; calls can be transferred to a live receptionist, and the AI plan is month-to-month with 30 days' notice to cancel (Smith.ai, 2026). Its hybrid page prices a mix of AI and live agents from about $2.50 a call. For a law firm, the question is less which approach is more advanced and more how a nervous prospective client will experience the first contact, and whether the answers they give will be captured accurately enough for intake.

Smith.ai starting price per call by answering approach, November 2026 Horizontal bars, starting price per call in dollars: AI-first 1.60; hybrid New Client Priority preset 2.50; hybrid Highest Touch preset 3.10; hybrid After Hours Only preset 3.70; human-first 7.00. Source: Smith.ai hybrid pricing page, checked November 13, 2026. The more humans, the higher the per-call price Smith.ai starting price per call, USD, by approach AI-first from $1.60 Hybrid: New Client Priority from $2.50 Hybrid: Highest Touch from $3.10 Hybrid: After Hours Only from $3.70 Human-first from $7.00 Source: Smith.ai hybrid pricing page, checked Nov 13, 2026.
Hybrid sends new-client calls to people and the rest to AI. Ruby sells only the human approach, with AI assisting its receptionists. Source: Smith.ai, 2026.

Which fits your firm?

Ruby fits firms whose calls are mostly short: messages, existing clients checking in, simple scheduling, where per-minute pricing keeps costs predictable and a warm human voice matters most. Smith.ai fits firms that want structured intake on new-client calls, with screening questions, a name search and a booked consultation on the same call, and that are comfortable paying per call for those steps. High-volume firms with simple calls may also look at Smith.ai's AI plans. Whichever you choose, run it for a month and check every new-client call log against the response standard in our intake guide.

What do the ethics rules expect when a service answers for your firm?

The ABA Model Rules treat an outside answering service as nonlawyer assistance: Comment [3] to Model Rule 5.3 says that when using services outside the firm, "a lawyer must make reasonable efforts to ensure that the services are provided in a manner that is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations" (ABA Model Rule 5.3, Comment [3]). The same comment lists the terms of any arrangement protecting client information as one of the factors, so read each vendor's confidentiality and data terms before you forward a line.

The caller is often a prospective client. Under Model Rule 1.18, the duty to protect what a prospective client shares "exists regardless of how brief the initial conference may be" (Comment [3]), and a lawyer weighing a new matter "should limit the initial consultation to only such information as reasonably appears necessary for that purpose" (Comment [4]) (ABA Model Rule 1.18, Comments). ABA Formal Opinion 492 (June 9, 2020) explains when information from a prospective client is "significantly harmful" enough to bar the firm from representing the other side (ABA, 2020). In practice: write the script so the receptionist collects the names for the conflict search and the facts needed to route the call, and no more; if you buy Smith.ai's six extra intake questions, choose them with that limit in mind. Your state's version of these rules controls, and our conflict check process guide covers what happens after the name search.

What will you still have to own?

The follow-up. An answering service captures the inquiry and can book the consultation, but the firm still needs a named person who reviews every new inquiry the same day, confirms the conflict result with the attorney, and makes sure booked consultations happen, as in our no-show fixes. The service is the front door; the firm's intake system decides whether anyone walks through it.

Where we stand FirmFooting builds operational systems. We are not a law firm and do not give legal advice. We take no affiliate fees, referral payments or sponsorships from any vendor named here. Vendor facts and prices were checked against vendor pages on Nov 13, 2026; vendors change plans often, so confirm current pricing and features before buying. Software tracks and surfaces work; the attorney owns the law, the official docket and every judgment. Each system supplements, never replaces, the firm's official docketing and the attorney's own record of critical dates. Nothing here is legal advice.

Where to go next

Answer every call, own every follow-up

Book the free audit to see where your inquiries leak, before or after choosing a service. A diagnosis, not a pitch.

Frequently asked questions

Is Ruby or Smith.ai cheaper for a law firm?

It depends on call length. At list prices on Nov 13, 2026, the two cost the same when Ruby's billed time averages about 2 to 2.5 minutes per call: Ruby's entry plan is $250 for 50 minutes ($5.00 a minute) and Smith.ai's is $300 for 30 calls ($10.00 a call). Shorter calls favor Ruby; longer intake calls favor Smith.ai.

How much does Ruby cost per month?

On Nov 13, 2026, Ruby listed $250 for 50 receptionist minutes, $395 for 100, $720 for 200 and $1,725 for 500 a month, with no activation or setup fees and no long-term contract. Minutes are billed in 60-second increments, rounded up, and overage is billed at a plan rate Ruby does not publish.

How much does Smith.ai cost?

Smith.ai's human-first receptionist plans were $300 for 30 calls, $810 for 90 and $2,100 for 300 a month on Nov 13, 2026, with extra calls at $11.50, $10.50 and $8.50. Its AI receptionist starts with a free tier of 25 calls a month, and paid tiers start at $150 a month for 75 calls.

Does Smith.ai charge for spam calls?

Not on its receptionist plans, as long as the lines you forward pass caller ID. On the AI receptionist, answered calls count by default, with an allowance to remove up to 10% of calls each billing cycle as spam; calls from known spam numbers are filtered before they are answered.

Can Smith.ai or Ruby run conflict checks?

Smith.ai offers a conflict check against your CRM for $0.50 a call. That is a name search; whether a conflict exists is the attorney's decision. Ruby's legal page describes intake, scheduling and payment collection rather than a conflict check.

Do Ruby and Smith.ai answer calls 24/7 in Spanish?

Both answer 24/7. Ruby says optional Spanish bilingual service is included with every receptionist account at no extra cost, though one answer in its FAQ still limits bilingual service to weekday hours, so confirm coverage. Smith.ai offers a dedicated Spanish line for $1.00 a call.

Do they integrate with Clio?

Yes. Ruby lists a native Clio integration, and Smith.ai names Clio among the CRMs it sends call details to. Ruby also lists 8am MyCase, Filevine, Lawmatics, Law Ruler and Rocket Matter; Smith.ai lists 8am MyCase in its integrations directory and shows Lawmatics on its legal page.

Do Ruby and Smith.ai offer a money-back guarantee?

Yes. Ruby gives first-time customers a full refund if they cancel within 21 days or before using 500 receptionist minutes, whichever comes first. Smith.ai gives new clients a 30-day money-back guarantee covering the plan and add-ons up to $1,000, excluding overage.

Sources

  1. Ruby pricing page: receptionist and chat plans, checked Nov 13, 2026. ruby.com/pricing
  2. Ruby FAQs: billing increments, overage, contract, guarantee, Spanish service, AI, checked Nov 13, 2026. ruby.com/faqs
  3. Ruby legal page. ruby.com
  4. Ruby integrations page. ruby.com
  5. Ruby AI page. ruby.com/ai
  6. Smith.ai pricing page: human-first plans, add-ons, FAQ, checked Nov 13, 2026. smith.ai/pricing
  7. Smith.ai AI receptionist pricing, checked Nov 13, 2026. smith.ai
  8. Smith.ai hybrid pricing, checked Nov 13, 2026. smith.ai
  9. Smith.ai legal page. smith.ai/legal
  10. Smith.ai integrations directory. smith.ai/integrations
  11. Clio, Legal Trends Report 2024 secret-shopper results, press release, Oct 7, 2024. clio.com
  12. Clio, Legal Trends Report 2019. clio.com
  13. ABA Model Rule 5.3, Comment [3], read Nov 13, 2026. americanbar.org
  14. ABA Model Rule 1.18, Comments [3] and [4], read Nov 13, 2026. americanbar.org
  15. ABA Formal Opinion 492, June 9, 2020. americanbar.org