Personal Injury · Guide · Published Nov 19, 2026

Personal Injury Case Management Software: A Neutral Guide

For owners and case managers at personal injury firms of one to ten attorneys: the platforms that small firms shortlist, what each lists as its price today, what each says it does for the operations jobs, and a worksheet to run a fair demo.

Judge personal injury case management software on six operations jobs: intake, limitations dates, tasks, documents, client updates and reporting. As listed on Nov 19, 2026, CASEpeer ($90 to $160), Neos ($109 or $139) and MyCase ($50 to $150) publish per-user monthly prices; Filevine, Litify, SmartAdvocate and CloudLex sell by quote. Demo every shortlist on your own matters.

Key takeaways

  • Three PI-capable platforms list prices: CASEpeer at $90, $130 and $160 per user a month; Neos at $109 or $139, billed yearly, for firms with 3 or more users; MyCase at $50 to $130 billed yearly (all as listed Nov 19, 2026).
  • CloudLex states it "does not publish or authorize standard public per-user pricing" (CloudLex); Filevine, Litify, SmartAdvocate and Smokeball also sell by quote.
  • In ABA claims data for 2020 to 2023, administrative errors were 22.87% of claims and "failure to calendar properly" ranked first among them (ABA, Jul 29, 2026).
  • Firms of 1 to 5 attorneys drew 52.47% of claims in the same data (27.83% plus 24.64%; FirmFooting sum).
  • Limitations rules change: Florida's 2022 statutes listed a negligence action under four years, its 2025 statutes under two (Fla. Stat. 95.11). Any rules table in software needs an attorney's check.
Keep a second record of every limitations date

The free SOL Tracking Template is an Excel workbook that drafts each limitations date from your State Rules tab, marks it unverified until an attorney confirms it, warns at 180, 90, 60 and 30 days, and keeps a weekly Review Log.

Get the free SOL Tracking Template

For a small PI firm, software has one job above the rest: no limitations date gets missed. This guide covers the platforms small firms shortlist, from each vendor's own pages opened on Nov 19, 2026. We take no affiliate fees and do not rank vendors; we give you the scoring method instead. For the head-to-head of the two most common names, see CASEpeer vs Filevine.

How does the PI case management market sort out?

Into four groups, by who each product is built for and whether it publishes a price. Start with the group that matches your firm, then demo two or three products from it.

Decision table, vendor pages as listed Nov 19, 2026
GroupProductsBest whenWatch for
PI only, price listedCASEpeer, NeosA PI-only firm that wants to budget before the demoNeos is built for 3 or more users and billed yearly
PI only, by quoteCloudLex, LitifyA PI-only firm wanting a platform scoped to its volumeNo public price; Litify runs on Salesforce
Multi-practice, by quoteFilevine, SmartAdvocate, SmokeballA firm with PI plus other practice areasModules priced as separate parts; get it in writing
General, configured for PIMyCase, ClioA firm already on one, or with mixed practice areasClio for Personal Injury is an add-on with no listed price

Two notes on the names. Assembly Software links Needles and Trialworks as legacy products on its pricing page and offers in-house migration to Neos (Assembly, Neos page). Litify describes itself as built on a "Salesforce-powered foundation" (Litify).

What does PI case management software cost?

Three platforms publish a price that covers PI work; the rest quote. Every price below is the vendor's own, as listed on Nov 19, 2026, per user per month.

Listed prices and terms, as listed Nov 19, 2026
VendorPlans as listedBillingTerms stated
CASEpeerBasic $90, Pro $130, Advanced $160Per user a month"No long-term contract or setup fee required"
NeosEssentials $109, Premium $139; Platinum quoted"billed annually""built for firms with 3 or more users"
MyCaseBasic $50, Pro $100, Advanced $130 (yearly); $60, $120, $150 (monthly)Yearly or monthly"No long-term contract or setup fee is required"
ClioStarter from $49; Core, Signature, Elite "Get pricing"Per user a monthClio for Personal Injury is an add-on; no listed price
FilevineQuote onlyNot listed"Contact our sales team for a custom quote"
SmartAdvocateQuote onlyNot listedDemo request; no pricing page found
LitifyQuote onlyNot listedDemo request
CloudLexQuote onlyNot listedNo "standard public per-user pricing"
SmokeballQuote only (Bill, Boost, Grow, Prosper+)Not listedDepends on users, plan, "contract term" and options

Sources: each vendor's pricing page, linked in the sources list. Prices exclude add-ons, data migration and e-signature where the vendor lists those separately.

Annual list cost for a five-user firm, plans that include intake and task tools Horizontal bars, FirmFooting calculation of list price times 5 users times 12 months. MyCase Pro billed yearly: 6,000 dollars. Neos Essentials: 6,540. CASEpeer Pro: 7,800. MyCase Advanced billed yearly: 7,800. Neos Premium: 8,340. CASEpeer Advanced: 9,600. Prices as listed Nov 19, 2026. Listed plans land between $6,000 and $9,600 a year Five users, 12 months, list price. FirmFooting calculation. MyCase Pro Neos Essentials CASEpeer Pro MyCase Advanced Neos Premium CASEpeer Advanced $6,000 $6,540 $7,800 $7,800 $8,340 $9,600 $0$2.5K$5K$7.5K$10K
Annual list cost, five users. MyCase Pro $6,000 (yearly billing; $7,200 monthly); Neos Essentials $6,540; CASEpeer Pro $7,800; MyCase Advanced $7,800 (yearly); Neos Premium $8,340; CASEpeer Advanced $9,600. FirmFooting calculation from vendor pricing pages as listed Nov 19, 2026 (CASEpeer, Assembly, MyCase). Excludes add-ons; quote-only vendors cannot be shown.

What does each platform say it does for the operations jobs?

Read the table as "what the vendor states on its own pages," not as a test result. "Not stated" means we did not find it on the pages we opened, not that the product lacks it: ask in the demo.

Operations jobs, vendor pages as listed Nov 19, 2026
JobCASEpeerNeosFilevineMyCase
Limitations datesAutomated statute alerts and notifications, every planStatute alerts, statute calculators, a 30-day SOL filter"statute of limitations alerts" on the dashboardCalendar on every plan; no SOL feature named on the pricing page
Court rulesCalendarRules integration, Pro and AdvancedNot statedTimely: "court rules for all 50 states"Court rules calendaring, Pro and Advanced, "requires subscription"
IntakeIntake management, forms and lead tracking, Pro and AdvancedIntake forms, intake CRM and lead tracking, EssentialsIntake packageIntake forms and legal CRM, Pro and Advanced
TasksTask workflows, every planWorkflows assign each task to a personTasks and custom workflowsTasks on every plan; workflows Pro and Advanced
Client updatesPortal every plan; two-way texting Pro and AdvancedTexting on Platinum; portal not statedClient Portal and messagingPortal (limited on Basic); texting Pro and Advanced
DocumentsManagement and automation, every planAssembly and management; OCR and Bates on PremiumTracks which providers still owe recordsGeneration Pro; advanced automation Advanced
ReportingBasic; more on Pro; multi-office on AdvancedReports and dashboards, EssentialsNot stated on pages openedCustomizable reporting, every plan
SecurityAWS hosting, rolling backups, two-factor loginNot statedAnnual SOC 2 Type II audit; backups at least every 15 minutesNot stated on the pricing page

The quote-only PI platforms state similar coverage. SmartAdvocate says "SOLs, Critical Deadlines and Appointments are pushed to staff's calendars," and lists an Intake Wizard, WorkPlans, texting, a client portal and a SOC 2 page that does not name the report type (SmartAdvocate). CloudLex lists texting, calendar, reminders and automated workflows on its base plan, with intake qualification on Advanced (CloudLex). Litify lists dynamic intake questionnaires and Matter Plans that create stages and tasks when a case opens. Clio lists calendaring and "templated groups of tasks" on every plan and "SOC 2 & ISO 27001" (Clio).

How should the software handle limitations dates?

As a date the attorney confirms, with an owner, a backup and warnings that reach a second person. Alerts are not a system. The ABA's malpractice data shows why the system matters more than the feature:

Legal malpractice claims by alleged error, ABA Profile, 2020 to 2023 One 100 percent stacked bar. Substantive errors 51.01 percent, the lawyer's craft, in grey. Administrative errors 22.87 percent and client relations 17.26 percent, the system's job, in green. Intentional wrongs 8.85 percent in dark grey. Failure to calendar properly is the top administrative error. Source: ABA Standing Committee on Lawyers' Professional Liability, CLE materials, Jul 29, 2026. Four in ten claims sit where a system can reach Share of claims by alleged error, ABA Profile, 2020 to 2023 51.01% 22.87% 17.26% 8.85% Substantive (the lawyer's craft) Administrative Client relations Intentional wrongs No. 1 administrative error: failure to calendar properly. No. 3: failure to react to calendar.
Where claims come from. Substantive 51.01%, administrative 22.87%, client relations 17.26%, intentional 8.85% of claims, 2020 to 2023. Source: ABA Standing Committee on Lawyers' Professional Liability, CLE materials, Jul 29, 2026. All practice areas, not PI alone; "failure to know or ascertain a deadline" is ranked sixth among substantive errors.

Software holds the date; people decide it. Periods differ by state and change by statute, so a vendor's rules table is a starting point that an attorney confirms for each matter. A few examples of the general personal injury period, for illustration only:

Examples of general periods, as written in the statute (exceptions apply)
StateStatutePeriod as writtenWhat it means for the software
CaliforniaCode Civ. Proc. 335.1"Within two years"Rules table entry, confirmed by the attorney per matter
New YorkCPLR 214(5)"within three years"Exceptions in other sections, so no auto-date without review
Florida (2022)95.11(3)(a)Negligence: four yearsAn old template still holds this
Florida (2025)95.11(5)(a)Negligence: two yearsChanged by HB 837, effective Mar 24, 2023; the attorney decides which applies

Statute text opened Nov 19, 2026. Not legal advice: limitations periods have exceptions and accrual rules; the attorney determines every date. Check your state's statutes and your state bar's guidance.

So in the demo, ask how a date is entered, who confirms it, whether the record shows who confirmed it and when, who is warned and how early, and what happens when nobody acts. The full method is in PI statute-of-limitations tracking, and chained dates are in the SOL chain build.

How much do intake and client updates matter in the choice?

A lot, because both are where small firms slip. In a 2025 vendor study of more than 1,300 law firm websites, 26% of PI firms never responded to an online lead and 25% replied in under five minutes (Hennessey Digital, Jun 24, 2025). In Illinois in 2025, discipline charges for neglect (1,335) and failing to communicate (736) led the list, and tort matters drew 564 charges (Illinois ARDC).

Illinois disciplinary charges by area of law, 2025 Horizontal bars, number of charges docketed in 2025. Criminal or quasi-criminal 1,176. Domestic relations 968. Tort, personal injury or property damage, 564, highlighted. Real estate or landlord-tenant 495. Probate 344. Immigration 254. Source: Illinois ARDC 2025 Annual Report, Chart 14. Tort matters ranked third in Illinois charges Charges docketed in 2025 by area of law, Illinois ARDC Criminal Domestic relations Tort (PI) Real estate Probate Immigration 1,176 968 564 495 344 254 03006009001,200
Where grievances land. Criminal 1,176; domestic relations 968; tort (personal injury or property damage) 564; real estate 495; probate 344; immigration 254 charges, 2025. Source: Illinois ARDC 2025 Annual Report, Chart 14. Counts, not rates; discipline data, not malpractice data.

"Disciplinary matters continue to occur disproportionately among solo practitioners and small firm lawyers."

Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission, 2025 Annual Report

So weigh how the platform handles a new inquiry (forms, a lead list, who gets notified) and a client update during treatment (portal, texting, templates), and whether texts and portal messages land in the matter record. The response standard is in PI intake speed; the records chase, as records management, is in the medical records workflow.

Security belongs in the same conversation. North Carolina's Rule 1.6(c) asks a lawyer to make "reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation of a client" (NC State Bar), and Comment [8] to its Rule 1.1 covers "the benefits and risks associated with the technology" (NC Rule 1.1). Ask every vendor for two-factor login, permission levels, backups and a named independent audit. Check your own state bar's rules.

Pick the software after the system is clear

The Zero-Miss Deadline System installs date ownership, escalation and the weekly review inside whatever platform you run. See what operations consulting costs before you budget the switch.

See operations consulting costs

How do you run a fair demo? The worksheet

Score every shortlisted product the same way, on your own matters (matter numbers only), and score a quote-only vendor on its written quote. Each criterion scores 2 (shown working in the demo), 1 (partly, or only on a higher plan) or 0 (not shown), times its weight: 28 points at most.

The PI software demo worksheet
#CriterionWeightShow me, on our matterScore (0 to 2)
1Limitations dates3Enter a date, record who confirmed it, and show the warning reaching a second person____ x 3
2Intake2A web inquiry becomes a lead, then a matter, with no retyping____ x 2
3Tasks2Opening a matter creates its standard tasks with owners and due dates____ x 2
4Client updates2Send a scheduled update by text and portal; both saved to the matter____ x 2
5Documents1Generate a letter from a template; find a records request by provider____ x 1
6Reporting1One screen of every open date by owner for the next 90 days____ x 1
7Security1Two-factor login, permission groups and a named audit report____ x 1
8Price and terms2A written price for every module you need, the contract term and the export terms____ x 2

Time each walkthrough and count the clicks for steps 1 and 4: your staff will repeat them thousands of times. If you are moving platforms, add a ninth check that is pass or fail: an export of every open matter with its limitations date, so the count of open dates in the old system equals the count in the new one on cut-over day. The configuration-first method covers the rest of the selection.

Worked example: a five-user PI firm compares listed prices

Worked example, not a client. A three-attorney PI firm has five users: three attorneys, a case manager and an intake coordinator. It wants intake tools, task workflows and texting, and will pay yearly.

Shortlist cost and coverage, five usersWorked example, list prices Nov 19, 2026
PlanYear, listIntakeWorkflowsTextingNext step
MyCase Pro$6,000YesYesYesDemo; ask about SOL alerts
Neos Essentials$6,540YesAsk by planPlatinum onlyDemo; ask Platinum quote
CASEpeer Pro$7,800YesYesYesDemo on 3 matters
FilevineQuotePackageYesAskWritten quote by module

The cheapest list price is not the answer by itself: MyCase Pro's pricing page names no statute alert, Neos lists texting and advanced workflows on Platinum, which is quoted, and Filevine's real price is unknown until the quote. The firm demos all four on three closed matters (MAT-1041, MAT-1057, MAT-1062), scores each on the worksheet, and decides on points per dollar with the written quote in hand. The figures are list prices, not results.

Mistakes to avoid

  1. Buying the alert instead of the system. Fix: an owner, a backup, warnings at fixed intervals and a weekly review, configured in whatever you buy.
  2. Trusting a vendor's rules table. Fix: the attorney confirms every limitations date, and the record shows who and when.
  3. Comparing a list price with a quote you have not seen. Fix: get every quote in writing, module by module, before scoring.
  4. A canned demo. Fix: the vendor works on your matters, using the worksheet above.
  5. Switching without reconciling dates. Fix: count open limitations dates before and after migration; they must match.
Where we stand FirmFooting builds operational systems. We are not a law firm and do not give legal advice. We take no affiliate fees, referral payments or sponsorships from any vendor named here, and we do not rank vendors. Prices and features come from each vendor's own pages as listed on Nov 19, 2026; confirm both before buying. The attorney owns the law, the official docket and every limitations period. Each system supplements, never replaces, the firm's official docketing.

By the numbers

Every figure on this page
FigureWhat it measuresSourceDate
$90 to $160CASEpeer price per user a month, three plansCASEpeerNov 19, 2026
$109 / $139Neos Essentials and Premium per user a month, billed yearly, 3+ usersAssemblyNov 19, 2026
$50 to $150MyCase per user a month, yearly to monthly billingMyCaseNov 19, 2026
$49Clio starting price per user a month (Starter)ClioNov 19, 2026
$6,000 to $9,600Annual list cost, five users, six plans (FirmFooting calculation)Vendor pagesNov 19, 2026
22.87%Malpractice claims from administrative errorsABA2020 to 2023
52.47%Claims against firms of 1 to 5 attorneys (FirmFooting sum)ABA2020 to 2023
26%PI firms that never answered an online lead (vendor study)Hennessey Digital2025
1,335 / 736Illinois charges: neglect / failing to communicateIllinois ARDC2025
564Illinois charges arising from tort mattersIllinois ARDC2025
4 to 2 yearsFlorida negligence period, 2022 vs 2025 statutesFla. Stat. 95.112022, 2025

Frequently asked questions

What is the best case management software for a small personal injury firm?

There is no single answer, so we do not rank vendors. Start with the group that fits your firm: PI-only with a listed price (CASEpeer, Neos), PI-only by quote (CloudLex, Litify), multi-practice by quote (Filevine, SmartAdvocate, Smokeball), or a general platform configured for PI (MyCase, Clio). Then score two or three on the demo worksheet.

Which PI case management tools publish their prices?

As listed on Nov 19, 2026: CASEpeer at $90, $130 and $160 per user a month; Neos at $109 or $139 per user a month billed yearly for firms with 3 or more users; MyCase at $50 to $130 billed yearly or $60 to $150 monthly; and Clio from $49 for its Starter plan. Filevine, Litify, SmartAdvocate, CloudLex and Smokeball sell by quote.

Does PI software calculate the statute of limitations for us?

Some platforms offer statute alerts, calculators or court-rules add-ons, but the attorney determines every limitations period. Periods have exceptions and change by statute, so treat any rules table as a draft the attorney confirms, and keep a second record.

What happened to Needles and Trialworks?

Assembly Software links Needles and Trialworks as legacy products on its pricing page and offers an in-house migration to Neos, its cloud platform for personal injury firms.

Should a small PI firm use Clio or MyCase instead of PI-only software?

It can, especially with mixed practice areas or if the firm already runs one. Price the configuration work and any PI add-on, and demo the same three jobs: a limitations date, a new inquiry and a client update.

Is this guide sponsored?

No. FirmFooting takes no affiliate fees, referral payments or sponsorships from any vendor, and uses only what each vendor states on its own pages.

Sources

  1. CASEpeer, pricing page (plans, prices and plan features, as listed Nov 19, 2026). casepeer.com/pricing
  2. Assembly Software, pricing page and Neos page (Nov 19, 2026). assemblysoftware.com/pricing; assemblysoftware.com/neos
  3. MyCase, pricing page (Nov 19, 2026). mycase.com/pricing
  4. Clio, pricing page (Nov 19, 2026). clio.com/pricing
  5. Filevine: pricing, personal injury, Timely, security (Nov 19, 2026).
  6. SmartAdvocate: home page; SOC 2 page (Nov 19, 2026).
  7. Litify, plaintiff practice management page (Nov 19, 2026). litify.com
  8. CloudLex, pricing page (Nov 19, 2026). cloudlex.com
  9. Smokeball, pricing page (Nov 19, 2026). smokeball.com/pricing
  10. ABA Standing Committee on Lawyers' Professional Liability, The Law Firm Liability Landscape, CLE materials, Jul 29, 2026 (Profile of Legal Malpractice Claims, 2020 to 2023). PDF
  11. Illinois Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission, 2025 Annual Report (charges by type; Chart 14 by area of law). iardc.org (PDF)
  12. California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1. leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
  13. New York Civil Practice Law and Rules section 214. nysenate.gov
  14. Florida Statutes section 95.11, 2022 and 2025 editions; CS/CS/HB 837 (2023), Chapter 2023-15. 2022; 2025; HB 837
  15. Hennessey Digital, 2025 List of Fastest-Responding Personal Injury Firms, Jun 24, 2025 (vendor study). hennessey.com
  16. North Carolina State Bar, Rules of Professional Conduct: Rule 1.6(c); Rule 1.1, Comment [8].

Where to go next

Before you sign, check that every limitations date has two names

Start with the free SOL Tracking Template as your second record of every limitations date. Then book the free 30-minute Missed-Deadline Risk Audit: we look at how your dates are owned and escalated, using matter numbers only.